The Chanin Building, 122 East 42nd Street, Suite 725, New York, New York 10168

Blog Post

$300 Million—Plus Ruling Favors NJ Transit Against Insurer—Words Matter!

$300 Million—Plus Ruling Favors NJ Transit Against Insurer—Words Matter! by Evan Schwartz

In light of the recent hurricanes that have decimated parts of the United States, Puerto Rico and the Caribbean, it is important to remember that ongoing battles that resulted from older natural disasters continue—in particular, from Superstorm Sandy.

Last month, a New Jersey judge ruled that the New Jersey Transit Authority is not subject to a $100 million cap for its flood losses suffered in connection with Sandy. This ruling is significant in that the damages exceed $400 million—more than $300 million of which has been in dispute. 

This case brings to the forefront a discussion about the words and language in a policy, particularly: 

•What do they mean?

•What do they mean in relationship to the insured and the insurance company?

•How do the courts interpret insurance policy provisions? 

In Sandy’s case, extensive damage occurred overall—especially to New Jersey Transit’s tracks, bridges, tunnels, and power stations. The underwriters of NJ Transit’s insurance company (Lloyd’s Syndicate) had issued coverages for significant losses. The insurance policy had windstorm definitions—including storm surge and wind-driven water—that was not excluded by the surge of surface water (which is excluded under the flood exclusion).

In this summary judgment ruling in favor of NJ Transit against the insurance company, the interpretation of the language partly involved the meaning of flood surge vs. wind-driven rain and water.

The inability to distinguish which one was which led the judge to rule in favor of the more specific and controlling provision. Since the surface water surge appeared in both sections of the policy (and both sections referenced it), the judge ruled that the section that actually provides coverage is the one that applies.

When interpreting insurance policies that have conflicts in language, it is not uncommon to rule in favor of an insured because the insurance companies usually draft the language in the first place. In addition, a traditional doctrine called The Reasonable Expectations of the Insured—what the insured reasonably believes the coverage would be—is also used in interpreting policies, and was used in this case.

Superstorm’s Sandy’s decimation of the state of New Jersey surely influenced the result as well. Nonetheless, insurance companies ordinarily don’t escape coverage when it’s given in one part of the policy and taken away in another.

Please contact us with any questions or comments.

Evan-Schwartz

 

Evan S. Schwartz
Founder of Schwartz Law
800-745-1755
moc.c1508300043pwalz1508300043trawh1508300043cs@SS1508300043E1508300043


what our clients say about us

Testimonials

  • Before choosing Schwartz law I was overwhelmed and confused about the whole LTD process and wanted to make sure I wasn’t making any wrong decisions for me and my family.

    Telecommunications Manager
  • Once a high functioning sales and trading VP at a bulge bracket investment bank, I began to really struggle emotionally esp. after the ongoing stresses of some devastating family health

    Trading VP, Bulge Bracket Investment Bank (original job in New Jersey)
  • Applying for disability, even when the need has become obvious to both yourself and those around you, is not necessarily an easy decision. In my case it meant having to

    Law Firm Partner
  • When I came to see Evan Schwartz, I had already shut down my business, was in the midst of a horrible divorce, had no income and hadn’t even filed a

    Business owner
  • Evan Schwartz and his team of lawyers fought for me like no one has ever for fought for me before. After a series of bad experiences with both doctors and

    IT Director

Latest News

Send us a message

Please leave this field empty.

Manhattan Offices

The Chanin Building, 122 East 42nd Street, Suite 725, New York, New York 10168

Toll Free: (800) 745-1755
Phone: (212) 608-5445

Garden City Office

666 Old Country Road, Ninth Floor, Garden City, New York 11530

Toll Free: (800) 745-1755
Phone: (516) 745-1122
Fax: (516) 745-0844