The Chanin Building, 122 East 42nd Street, Suite 725, New York, New York 10168

Blog Post

Mediating a Long-Term Disability Case: The New Norm?

Mediating a Long-Term Disability Case: The New Norm? by Evan Schwartz

After having mediated hundreds of—and settled well over a thousand—long-term disability cases, I have found that mediation has now become the standard in the long-term disability industry for resolving disputed claims.                         

It is not only the standard, but it is the preferred method for the insurance companies to mediate, and they like to have a neutral person serve as mediator. They prefer to physically attend the mediation with the insured rather than just having the lawyers do it. Although I do resolve certain cases without mediation, it has become a much smaller percentage of how cases settle. 

Mediations occur prior to the commencement of a lawsuit, but they typically take place well before trial. This usually happens after you, the insured, have had your deposition taken by the insurance company’s lawyer. At this point, the insurance company now has most of the documents they need to evaluate the merits of your case and have now heard your side of the story. Equally as important, by taking your deposition, they get to assess your credibility as a witness. The insurance company now has a far better understanding of you and the strength of your case.                            

Mediation is usually an excellent opportunity for the parties to see if they can come together and settle the case. Mediation is a voluntary process, and neither side is required to settle the case. Keep in mind that everything said at the mediation is kept completely confidential. 

Long-term disability cases are typically all or nothing propositions. Either you are going to win and get everything, or you are going to lose and get nothing. So, given the pressure and the cost of a trial, along with the risk involved, mediation is a great opportunity to get your case settled.                      

Although mediation can be a time-consuming and stressful process, the hours involved will pale in comparison to the hours you will put in preparing with your attorneys for the daunting experience of a trial. Patience during mediation is the word that I like to emphasize to all of my clients. It may seem, early on, that the mediation is going to be an aggravating process, and someone might want to walk out, but your job when you are there—and your lawyer’s job—is to get the most amount of money the insurance company is willing to pay, and then determine whether or not it is enough for you.

Once you determine the maximum amount the insurance company is willing to pay, you know exactly what it is that you are walking away from if you reject the settlement offer and go to trial.

If you have any questions about mediation or the process involved in mediating a long-term disability case, don’t hesitate to call us today at 212-608-5445 for a free consultation.



Evan S. Schwartz
Founder of Schwartz Law

  • March 14, 2017
what our clients say about us


  • When I came to see Evan Schwartz, I had already shut down my business, was in the midst of a horrible divorce, had no income and hadn’t even filed a

    Business owner
  • Evan Schwartz and his team of lawyers fought for me like no one has ever for fought for me before. After a series of bad experiences with both doctors and

    IT Director
  • As a dentist with a private practice knowing I had no choice but to file a long term disability claim, hiring the right law firm was one of the most

  • As Vice President of a large brokerage firm, I did anticipate having a problem with Hartford Insurance Company and, for that reason, I was advised to apply for long term

    V.P. Brokerage Firm
  • Dear Michail: I just received the box containing my copy of the appeal you sent to the insurance company. To say I was overwhelmed would be a complete understatement. My

    Financial Services Manager

Latest News

Send us a message

Please leave this field empty.

Manhattan Offices

The Chanin Building, 122 East 42nd Street, Suite 725, New York, New York 10168

Toll Free: (800) 745-1755
Phone: (212) 608-5445

Garden City Office

666 Old Country Road, Ninth Floor, Garden City, New York 11530

Toll Free: (800) 745-1755
Phone: (516) 745-1122
Fax: (516) 745-0844